Organology: Harp Guitar "Relatives"

Note to the casual reader or researcher: This Reference Gallery features historical instruments that are not harp guitars, but “relatives” or distant “cousins” – presented on Harpguitars.net for historical and organological comparison.

Mixed Family Hybrids & Other Related Forms
by Gregg Miner

Updated February, 2012

Non-family specific instruments similar or related to harp guitars. Many can be considered "hybrids" or "one-offs."

See bottom of page for image copyright information

      French

Naderman (Jean-Henri) bissex, Paris, 1773 Pacquet bissex, Marseille, 1774 Thiphanon (Jean-François) bissex, Paris, 1780 Caron
Guitare decacorde,
1784
© Yale University Collection of Musical Instruments
Photo credit: Alex Contreras
Caron
Guitare decacorde,
1785

Note: Despite the bissex' name ("twice six"), the 2 distinct nuts carrying 6 strings each, and what has been previously been written (Baines, et al) the tuning is not 6 standard neck strings and 6 descending basses. According to Joscelyn Godwin (1974) the tuning is the then-standard five neck strings (down to A), then the first sub-bass G still on the same neck, continuing on to the second neck with F-E-D-C-B-A.  Thus, it is the same principle as Carulli's decacorde (several decades later) that descended to C.  To clarify, while strung as (6+6), it is tuned 7+5, where Carulli's is (5+5).

While all researchers (including Godwin) point out the sharping levers for the six longer bass strings, the photos clearly show that there are eight levers, one for each of the 7 "extra" strings, plus the standard A (5th string) on the neck (the highest string lever appears broken off). The bissex by Thiphanon also has 8 sharping levers.

A third bissex by the obscure violin maker Pacquet, was hiding in plain site at the Paris museum, alongside its other two. It had been labeled "arpi-guitarre" - but after questioning by myself and Benoit Meulle-Stef (late 2011), they realized it was, in fact, a bissex (the extension is broken off).  Note how the bridge, offset neck, body shape and distinctive 7-ribbed semi-flattened bowl are clearly patterned off the Naderman (with the Thiphanon version a seeming cross between these two). (click for larger images)

On each specimen, but especially the original invention, note how the body is more or less lute-shaped, with a staved, lute-style back.  There is an interesting Naderman document (discovered by Steve Sedgwick) that appears to show his bissex with flat guitar sides, though this may simply be poor artistic license by someone unfamiliar with the new instrument (a 2nd bissex is behind it). Some researchers consider this one of the "first harp guitars" or "oldest surviving harp guitar" - obviously, I consider it more of a "hybrid instrument" (it was created by a harp builder, strangely enough). If one does want to consider it a "harp guitar," I imagine they must also consider most every instrument on this page to also be "harp guitars."

The slightly later French 10-string instrument by Caron is more of a mystery. Note how the gut strings of his invention attach to the tail block.  Two similar specimens are known, with the right one (Paris) showing a fascinating string sharping system for the 4 sub-basses.

The tuning is not known.  Again, if the name is accurate, one is tempted to theorize standard guitar tuning for the 6 neck strings (which was not unknown, but still rare, in 1785).  Godwin postulates a tuning which would appear in a similar, but much later, 1848 instrument, with the known tuning of G A Bb C / d f a c' e' g'.  This is certainly likely, as it resembles that of the French arch-cittern of the same general time frame.

Regardless of tuning, the form alone makes it more of a hybrid invention, like the bissex.

Swedish
This first group of instruments include what I classify as "true Swedish lutes."  Following below are what I term "false Swedish lutes."  While many scholars are aware of and discuss the differences, many lump the two indiscriminately together, as do some modern makers who reproduce both instruments.  The true Swedish lute is a12 to 15-course instrument strung in gut, with 8 strings on the neck (sometimes doubling the 3 high strings) and 4, 5 or 7 open bass strings. The tuning, developed from the English guitar, was an "open" chord on top with descending basses, much like the Light harp-lutes.  Note that I therefore do not include these makers in the Encyclopedia, but that I do include makers of "false Swedish lutes," which share the harp guitar's configuration, tuning and playing technique (and were often made and marketed side by side by various shops).

This group of exquisite, rare photos comes from the Stockholm Music Museum.

Kraft, Mathias Petter, Stockholm, Sweden
177x (8+4, 3 neck strings doubled) 1790 (8+5) 1792 (8+4) 1794 (8+7)

Johan Jerner, Stockholm, Sweden
1791 (8+5) 1792 (8+5) 1797 (8+7 1808 (8+7)

Anders Odendahl,
Stockholm?, Sweden, 1812
(8+7)
Erik Ryberg, Uddevalla, Sweden, 181[1?]
(8+7)
Lorens Mollenberg, Stockholm, Sweden, 1815
(8+7)
Unknown, Stockholm?, Sweden, 1800s
(8+7)
German, Swedish, Danish
Here are the endless varieties of what I classify as either "theorboed guitar-lutes" or "false Swedish lutes" - depending (generally) on the body shape (regardless of country of origin).  Originally, the former were (and still are) called "bass-lutes" (Germany), while the latter were/are known as Nordic bass-lutes (Germany) or Swedish lutes or Scholander-lutes (Sweden: named after its most famous player [see Iconography: Harp Guitar Relatives]). As stated above, the "true" Swedish lute from a century earlier (above) was a somewhat different instrument (see Organology Part I).

Instruments in this first group are basically all similar theorboed versions of the "guitar-lutes" that were very common from 1890-1920. They are as close to a true harp guitar as you can get, and were played by guitar players exactly like harp guitars. All have a standard 6-string guitar neck and generally 4 or 6 sub-basses. The body is of standard lute shape. Not just a wandering minstrel's "folk" instrument, many were built by the finest guitar makers and played by well-known guitarists.

Adolf Paulus, 1924 Hermann Hauser, Munich 1924 Hermann Hauser, 1931 Heinrich Fuchs, 1920s Halbmeyer, 1904 Halbmeyer, Munich, 1909
(spelled Halbmaier on label)
J. H. Zimmerman, Liepzig, 1900s

Gotz (or Goetz?) Paul Kochendörfer, 1923 Sinfonia, Markneukirchen Goldklang M. Zimmer, Nuremberg

Meinel & Herold "Otwin" brand, Otto Windisch company Schuster Brothers (Gebrüder Schuster) Markneukirchen, 1920s C. A. Wunderlich, Siebenbrunn (near Markneukirchen)
1938
Wilhelm Kruse, Markneukirchen Heinr. Moritz Schuster, Markneukirchen

Gunter Penzel, Markneukirchen, new Steffen Gläsel, Markneukirchen, 1999 A. Höllinger,
Kiel, Germany
August Schulz Otto Tittmann Morik Heinel, Markneukirchen

Unknown, 5-bass Unknown, 9-bass Meinel & Herold, 9-bass
Instruments in this second group follow the body shape of the "true" Swedish lute.
"Swedish Lute" patent, date? J. H. Zimmerman, Liepzig, 1900s K. Meinel-Bartfritz, 1900 Alfred Brock, Stockholm, Sweden, 1910 Alfred Brock, Stockholm, Sweden, 1920
(6+2)

Paesold, Bohemia, pre-1918 Schuster Brothers (Gebrüder Schuster) Markneukirchen, 1920s "Otwin" brand, Otto Windisch company F. Jühling, Dresden, c.1911 Neuner & Hornsteiner, Markneukirchen Voight, Markneukirchen

Bo Wretling, Stockholm, Sweden, 1947 "Crafton" brand, Gothenburg, Sweden, c.1950 Johann H. Hoffman, Stockholm, Sweden, 1951

H. Levin, New York/Gothenburg, 1902 -1923 Levin, Gothenburg, Sweden, 1952 Wilhelm Kruse, Markneukirchen Goldklang Sällskapet Svenska Lutan. 2005
This third group consists of Danish theorboed guitar-lutes, which closely follow the Swedish lute shape.  Note the similarity and consistency of style of these first five Copenhagen makers.

The first 4 images are from the book Danish Guitars and Their Makers by Kenneth Brogger. 

Peder Stochholm, c.1910 Thorvald Lund, c.1925 Thorvald Lund, 1924 Johannes Moller, 1925 J.R. Rieche Einar Willadsen, Copenhagen, 1898

These strange theorboed guitar-lutes have bass extensions used on harp guitars, rather than the typical "bass-lute" configuration.
Unknown

The pear shape, lute back and bridge belong to the guitar-lute family. The headstocks, tuners and soundhole are pure harp guitar!

Herman Carlson Levin, 1927, Gothenburg, Sweden J. Tielke Patented Joachim Tielke Bass-laute, distributed by Otto Windisch company

Unknown

This strange instrument appears to be a German guitar-lute combined with the floating fingerboard concept of Pacquet's 1784 arpi-guitare - with a theorboed headstock for two sub-basses yet!

Unknown

In the expanded image, one can see the lute back of this very strange double-neck instrument. The headstocks and tuners also beggar description.

Additional Images

"Harfenlaute" patent, Johann Lührs
Rüstringen, Oldenburg
Nov 6, 1920

Patent # 346,447

"Harfen-Lauten" ("Harp-Lute") distributed by the Otto Windisch Company

(Available with either 9 or 12 basses!)

Was this instrument based on the previous patent?

 

Unknown
(Musikmuseum, Basel Switzerland)

         Russian   

torban, 19th century torban

          Ukraine

kobza-bandura hybrid kobza-bandura hybrid, 20th century

From researcher Jurij Fedynskyj : "To be more exact, in my opinion I'd call them both banduras, as the strings on the neck as most likely basses, and not melody strings. The presence of frets on one simply allow for bass line. Realistically, most kobzar banduras are frettable on the neck, but we don't call the instruments kobza-banduras."

     Misc.     

Boothe "sirelin," 1928,
Pat #1,684,467

Arling Shaeffer, Chicago, 1912
"Contra Bass Lute"
A theorboed version of a strange large-bodied bowl-back gut strung guitar Shaeffer called the "Eqyptian Lute" with his unique tuners.
In truth, this instrument by Halle does not belong on this page - or even site - at all.  In fact, it's not even a guitar!  It is just built like one, with a guitar body and -stretching it a bit - a neck and headstock.  But it is really some sort of fretless zither, either meant to be plucked or strummed.

 

To

What is a Harp Guitar?

To

Harp Guitar Family Tree

Back To

Photo Reference Library of Examples.

 


Harpguitars.net
Home

The Harp Guitar Foundation            The Harp Guitar Gathering®

History          Players         Music         Luthiers         Iconography         Articles 

 Forum                 About                Links                Site Map                Search               Contact

All Site Contents Copyright © Gregg Miner, 2004,2005,2006,2007,2008,2009,2010,2011,2012. All Rights Reserved.

Copyright and Fair Use of material and use of images: See Copyright and Fair Use policy.