Organology: Harp Guitar "Relatives"

Note to the casual reader or researcher: This Reference Gallery features historical instruments that are not harp guitars, but “relatives” or distant “cousins” – presented on Harpguitars.net for historical and organological comparison.

Extended Range Guitars
(also known as "Multi-stringed Guitars" or "Multi-course Guitars"*)
by Gregg Miner

Not to be confused with harp guitars, these are "extended-range" guitars with extra bass strings beyond the standard guitar's low E string (though some may be tuned higher than this low E). They are:

  • Fully fretted across all courses (7, 8 and 10 are common)

  • Every string is designed to have one or more of its frets utilized (fingered)

  • The player frets (stops with a left hand finger) every string in actual practice

Note: For instruments where one or more fretted strings are not fingered, see Fretted Harp Guitars.

See bottom of page for image copyright information

8-string guitar, Vicente Arias, 1899 Ramirez 10-string, 1973 Bartolex (China) 10-string guitar

Can be played as - and in such case, be "classified" or called - either an extended range guitar or fretted harp guitar


Peter Blanchette "archguitar" by Walter Stanul, 1981

Unlike the original, fully-fretted instrument (shown here), two of Stanul's early archguitars were harp guitar forms with theorboed basses (like James Kline's archguitars, made by others)

Richard DiCarlo

This 8 string was the brainstorm of guitarist Michele Ramo. The range of this instrument is 6 octaves. It is a 34-fret (high D) instrument. The 7th string is low A (.070) and the 8th string is double low D (.080, sometimes .100). The last two strings are played like a fretless bass. Being thus fingered with the left hand instead of played open, this hybrid instrument cannot be considered a harp guitar, but instead, a rare Multi-Course Fretted/Fretless Guitar combo.

ErmannoChiavi, Zurich, Switzerland

Tonaharp, c.1916,
Pat #1,168,153

A 3-tuning (5+5+7) Hawaiian guitar

There are many additional web site sources for Extended Range Guitars - specifically "10-string guitars" - but readers may want to start with these three that perhaps represent the three main "movements" - each with their own point of view and specific focus on surprisingly different versions of what otherwise look like identical instruments.  Guitar organology researchers should be able to easily ascertain the historical and musical differences between each.

www.tenstringguitar.INFO (Viktor Van Niekerk, proponent of the "true" Yepes ten-string guitar)
www.tenstringguitar.com/ (Janet Marlow, proponent of her own 10-string method)
www.cathedralguitar.com/ (classical guitarist Stephen Bright - who himself plays a "fretted harp guitar" - runs a site on multi-string guitars in general)

Regarding the recent practice of calling some of these instruments “classical harp guitars” (seen regularly on EBay, for example), it is my understanding that this is for marketing purposes, inspired by Stephen Bright’s choice of terms for his 10-string fretted instrument, which he says he often plays “in the manner of” a harp guitar (by not utilizing the frets for the lowest strings).  I have found that many players of various fully-fretted extended-range guitars admit that - in practice - they omit fretting some of their lower strings.  These can best be considered - and referred to as - Fretted Harp Guitars (that is, if "harp" must even enter into the discussion at all...).

Update: July, 2009: A visitor named Charles Wood - a 10-string (fretted) guitarist - took the time to carefully read, consider, and then meticulously present his opinions to me about the terminology and definition I previously presented here. Amazingly, we saw each other's point of view and agreed with each other.  What Charles was describing was the very real - and very nebulous - "gray area" of the instruments that I had originally addressed on this site under the formal classification "Fretted Harp Guitars."  Before too long, I had completely removed that page and term from the site, having decided that the harpolyre (in truth, also a "FHG") deserved its own page, as it is a very specific - and now understood - instrument.  I had also feared too much confusion regarding the term "fretted harp guitar" (which does, in fact, sound like an oxymoron!), and frankly, did not want to deal with the endless gray area and minutiae of the many "multi-string guitar" players.  So I put my (very clever) "fretted harp guitar" organology into mothballs.  But after Mr. Wood illustrated and convinced me that this issue will likely never go away - while at the same time offering clear examples and even new verbiage - I have re-identified the Fretted Harp Guitar here.

At the same time, I have tried to carefully rephrase the definition of "multi-course guitar" so that it stands apart from a "fretted harp guitar" (see my Definition at the top of this page).  Please note that little of this fits within the realm of harp guitar organology - this whole multi-string mess is simply a necessary evil - as there is much public confusion (and misinformation) about these instruments and how they relate to harp guitars.

My harp guitar colleague, John Doan (Professor, Willamette University), who submitted this correction to his 2007 Fingerstyle Magazine article, The Inevitable Harp Guitar, adds this to our discussion:

“Gregg Miner and I have spent many a conversation on what constitutes an instrument being an actual harp guitar given that he and I (among others) have tried to organize and encourage players of the instrument through recordings, the internet, and Gatherings.

My understanding in a nutshell:

The "guitar" is typically a fretted instrument especially good at rendering chords, melody, and counterpoint through fingering.  Its challenge is that you have to often do two things to get one note – finger (fret) and pluck.

The "harp" is typically played with one note per string allowing the player to do one thing to get one note (not two as on the guitar) but requiring many strings.  No fingers are used to shorten the strings.

The "harp guitar" is then an instrument that has a fretted section and an unfretted section (thus at least one floating string).

I not only respect Gregg’s work in this area I would also have to agree that, technically, we should not call Janet Marlow’s instrument (or Stephen Bright's 10-string) a true "harp guitar" even though it may be played "in the manner and technique of a harp guitar."

Correction: In my article "The Inevitable Harp Guitar" I was pointing out what I thought was the obvious - guitars (or lutes for that matter) tend to grow in numbers of strings over time (ie. 4 course renaissance guitar to a five course baroque guitar to a six string classical guitar and so forth).  I never saw anyone address this trend, much less try to explain why this happens!  To add weight to the article's point that this mechanism in guitar evolution is happening in our own time I created a list of contemporary players that was collated from my larger list of players of many instruments "beyond 6 strings" (including harp guitar and other extended range guitars). The sidebar ended up with a category "Classical Harp Guitarists" and when Gregg Miner pointed out a discrepancy to me in a proof I sent him, I contacted the editor to remove Janet Marlow's name (a fabulous player that goes beyond 6 strings, but technically not a harp guitarist), but the issue was already to the printer.”

- John Doan, 9/22/2008

John (arguably the harp guitar's second most knowledgeable and thoughtful scholar) and I agree, as do - judging from my email response and correspondence - the majority of this site's readership.  The instruments described here cannot be placed within the "harp guitar" category.  Yet, clearly, a specific term and definition are required for the very real conundrum - and increasingly common practice - of a fretted guitar played in the manner of a harp guitar.  For clarity and sanity's sake, my proffered term remains Fretted Harp Guitar.

* Course refers to a set of one, two or three strings that are tuned and played as a unit representing one note on an instrument.  Strings in a course can be tuned in unison or octaves.  Example: the mandolin has eight strings arranged in four courses – meaning four pairs of strings, the two strings of each pair being tuned the same and played together as a single “note.”  An instrument can have mixed courses, such as an 8-course Renaissance lute, which has 1 single course and 7 double courses. 

 

To

What is a Harp Guitar?

To

Harp Guitar Family Tree

Back To

Photo Reference Library of Examples.

 


Harpguitars.net
Home

The Harp Guitar Foundation            The Harp Guitar Gathering®

History          Players         Music         Luthiers         Iconography         Articles 

 Forum                 About                Links                Site Map                Search               Contact

All Site Contents Copyright © Gregg Miner, 2004,2005,2006,2007,2008,2009,2010,2011,2012. All Rights Reserved.

Copyright and Fair Use of material and use of images: See Copyright and Fair Use policy.